Oyster Rush

Black And White Photography, Photography, Stacy

Updated September 2, 2016: AND THE WINNER IS …

Okay, votes have been cast and the choice made. And interestingly, while “Travel Weary” received an actual vote (thanks, Joe 😊) and a few nods in the comments, my final choice came from the write-in titles, of which there were many. I don’t know if you were all able to see what those were, but for fun here they are: Inside the Oyster, Belly of the Beast, On Arrival, Destination, Our Rush, Every Which Way, An Old Tradition, Oyster Bar, To the Oyster Bar, Oyster Bar Restaurant, Follow the Tile, Oyster Rush, Activity, The World is Your Oyster.

What did I choose? Belly of the Beast captured the fancy of both me and my hubby, though those not familiar with Grand Central would likely not get the reference. In the end, it came down to Oyster Rush and Every Which Way. I really liked the feel of Every Which Way, but it left out any reference to the Oyster Bar. In the end, drumroll please, I chose Patti’s suggestion of “Oyster Rush.” Thanks, Patti!

Thanks so much to all for participating. It is so true that we each see things differently and this made it fun to learn what you all “saw” in this photo. (FYI, I chose a different title for the color image. I won’t spoil the surprise, but if you’re interested in learning about that, pop on over via the Visual Venturing link below.)

Oyster Bar Restaurant entrance Grand Central Station

Oyster Bar Restaurant, Grand Central Station, New York City

I’ve never had too much of a problem coming up with a title for a post. For some reason, this one has baffled me. I’ve always believed that if I can’t title an image, then my vision for it wasn’t clear, and therefore, neither will it be for the viewer. So I hesitated posting this one. Trouble is, I really like it. The reason for shooting was to capture the famous Oyster Bar Restaurant in the basement of Grand Central. It was a challenge as tripods aren’t allowed and the light is very low. Handholding with high ISO was the only way to go.

I loved the hustle and bustle of the area, but what caught my attention was the lone woman, head down, pulling her suitcase, making her way to the restaurant. That was the focus of my attention. As fate would have it, when I pushed the shutter, the young man entered the right of the frame – I love his motion. And in the color version, he’s wearing a blue shirt, which works together with the blue sweater the woman is wearing.

With that backstory, I then began to think about titles for this B&W post. (For the color version, “Blue” was the first idea I had, but when I asked my husband to look at the photo, he didn’t see that; he saw, instead, the woman, who was in fact the reason behind the photo. Obviously color is not an option here.)  “To the Bar?”  “Travel Weary?” “By One’s Lonesome?” After pondering this for far too long, I finally decided, hey, why don’t I ask all of you.

What makes this even more interesting is that I chose to post this photo in color on my own blog. If you’re up for it, head on over to Visual Venturing and see it. You’ll find a slightly different poll, with the inclusion of “blue” for a choice.

So, chime in and let me know if any of my titles appeal to you. Or perhaps you have a better idea. I’ll hold the poll open for one week and whatever title comes out on top is the one I’ll change the title to (unless I like someone’s “other” idea the best). It will be interesting to see if the top choices for both end up being the same or different. So have some fun and I thank you in advance for your input!

For more photos from New York City and beyond, visit VisualVenturing.com.

Advertisements

28 thoughts on “Oyster Rush

  1. Such a fabulous shot Stacy and, surprisingly I came up with a title quite quickly – Oyster Rush. I say surprised because sometimes it takes me ages to come up with titles for my own pics. I had never thought about the issue of a title translating into clarity for the viewer and I would happily not bother with a title at all. I could go on and on here about this but people will most often stamp their own view into the frame, seeing and feeling so much more than a simple passing moment. Love how you caught the blurry rush framing the solid stance of the older woman and the young girls with the detail of the tiled roof coming at us in successive waves.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Patti, I love how you describe the photo! And I guess you really have a very valid point about not needing to name our images – definitely in keeping with the age-old adage that a picture is worth a thousand words. It’s funny, but a while ago, WP had a Weekly Photo Challenge (something I used to participate in but haven’t done in quite some time) and the theme was “Arches.” I thought about this picture in the architectural sense for a bit, but really it was about the people IN this iconic NYC spot. Removed from here, the shot wouldn’t have been one I would have taken. So I do really like the title you came up with – combining the feel and the place. That being said, the decision is still out until I read and reply to all, and then I’ll pick, change the title, and follow-up with a comment 🙂 Thanks, as always, for your comment!

      Like

  2. “Destination”
    The picture is taken in Grand Central Station – a place used to help people get to their next destination of travel. Also, the woman headed to the Oyster Bar Restaurant is uniquely the only person in the shot whom you can clearly see what her intended destination is (which to me is what makes the picture so interesting).

    Liked by 1 person

  3. This is such a fantastic image Stacy and there is so much going on 🙂 If I had to choose a title from the options listed I would choose “Travel Weary” and I did. The first thing I noticed was the lone lady with the suitcase and thats probably because as a New Yorker I am so accustomed to this place. If I had to make a title up I would say “Belly Of The Beast” because this is the lower level of that magnificent structure called Grand Central Terminal 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

  4. It’s a great shot, and it already has a title – Oyster Bar Restaurant. You said yourself that your reason for shooting was to capture the restaurant. I barely noticed the woman, but my eye was drawn straight to the restaurant which pulled me right into the frame. Then what I noticed was the bustle and movement all around which tells me more about the restaurant. I think if you want to title this in some way about the woman you need to focus in on her more – and then you’d lose the wide shot which is so expressive like it is. Well that’s my two cents anyway. Cheers,
    Alison

    Liked by 2 people

Tell us what you think

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s